As American pet ownership continues to rise, dogs and cats are no longer just animals — they’re family. This emotional bond is driving the U.S. pet industry to record growth, and natural pet food has become one of the fastest-growing categories. According to the American Pet Products Association (APPA), over 72% of U.S. pet parents are willing to pay more for natural, additive-free, and high-quality pet food, pushing the natural pet food market to exceed $28 billion in 2024.
However, rapid growth also brings confusion. Some brands heavily market the word “natural,” yet fail to meet the true requirements. Many U.S. pet parents also lack clear knowledge about reading labels, ingredient sourcing, or AAFCO standards, often resulting in digestive issues, allergies, or long-term health problems for pets.
This guide breaks down the key standards, ingredient rules, top brands, buying channels, and practical buying tips—helping American pet owners confidently choose real natural pet food in 2025.
1. What Defines Natural Pet Food in the U.S.? Understanding AAFCO & FDA Standards
In the U.S., natural pet food is primarily regulated through:
- AAFCO (Association of American Feed Control Officials) guidelines
- FDA (Food and Drug Administration) pet food safety rules
To qualify as natural pet food, a product must meet three core standards:
1. Transparent Ingredients: No Vague Labels
High-quality natural pet food must clearly state:
✔ Exact protein sources (e.g., “deboned chicken,” “wild-caught salmon”)
✔ Country of origin (e.g., “USA-sourced turkey,” “New Zealand lamb”)
Avoid products that use vague terms like:
- “poultry meal”
- “animal by-product meal”
- “meat meal”
These may include low-quality scraps, feathers, or unidentified animal sources.
Quality natural foods commonly use:
- organic brown rice
- sweet potatoes
- oats
- vegetables like spinach or carrots
Instead of cheap fillers such as corn gluten meal or wheat by-products.
2. Zero Artificial Additives: No Hidden Chemicals
Authentic natural pet food must not contain:
✘ Artificial colors
✘ BHA/BHT (chemical preservatives)
✘ Ethoxyquin
✘ MSG or synthetic flavor enhancers
Instead, natural pet food uses safe, natural preservatives:
✔ Vitamin E (mixed tocopherols)
✔ Rosemary extract
✔ Green tea extract
If a label lists “natural flavor” without specifying the source, this is a red flag.
3. Nutritionally Complete: Must Meet AAFCO Life-Stage Standards
Every natural pet food should clearly state:
- “Meets AAFCO nutrient profile for… (growth / adult / all life stages)”, or
- “Formulated based on NRC nutrition standards”
AAFCO certification ensures complete and balanced nutrition.
Examples:
- Puppies/kittens: ≥ 22% protein, ≥ 8% fat
- Adults: moderate protein/fat levels
- Senior pets: lower phosphorus for kidney support
No certification = not safe for long-term feeding.
2. Natural Pet Food vs. Regular Kibble: What’s the Real Difference?
Many pet owners wonder whether natural pet food is worth the higher price. Here are the three major differences:
1. Ingredient Quality: Natural Starts at the Source
| Category | Regular Kibble | Natural Pet Food |
|---|---|---|
| Protein | Often “meat meal” or by-products | Fresh, deboned meat or wild-caught fish |
| Carbs | Corn, wheat, soy | Brown rice, oats, sweet potatoes |
| Additives | Artificial preservatives/colors | Natural antioxidants |
This ingredient quality directly affects digestion, allergies, and long-term immunity.
2. Digestibility: Natural Foods Require Smaller Portions
- Regular kibble digestibility: 60–70%
- Natural pet food digestibility: 85–90%
This means pets absorb more nutrients with smaller daily portions—saving money in the long run.
3. Long-Term Health: Fewer Vet Visits
Long-term consumption of low-quality food increases risks of:
- skin allergies
- obesity
- diabetes
- digestive disorders
- liver/kidney burden
In contrast, U.S. veterinary studies show that pets fed natural diets long-term:
- have 32% fewer skin problems
- and 28% fewer digestive issues
- with 1–2 years longer life expectancy on average
3. Top 5 Natural Pet Food Brands in the U.S. Market (2025 Edition)
1. Orijen (Canada) — Best for Sensitive Stomachs & High Protein Needs
Why it’s popular in the U.S.:
- 70%+ fresh meat content
- No grains, potatoes, or fillers
- Freeze-dried raw pieces increase digestibility
- Highly suitable for sensitive dogs/cats
Who should buy:
Pets with allergies, picky eaters, puppies, seniors.
2. Acana (Canada) — Best Value High-Quality Natural Food
Key advantages:
- Regionally sourced meats (prairie beef, Atlantic fish)
- Higher quality at a lower price than Orijen
- Added probiotics for gut health
Who should buy:
Families who want quality natural food at a moderate price.
3. Wellness Core (USA) — Best for Targeted Functional Nutrition
Benefits:
- Grain-free, high-protein formula
- Options for weight control, low-fat diets, or chicken-free diets
- High omega-3 and glucosamine levels
Who should buy:
Pets with allergies, obesity, or joint issues.
4. Blue Buffalo (USA) — Best Affordable Natural Pet Food
Pros:
- Meets AAFCO standards
- Affordable and widely available (Walmart, Amazon, Target)
- Has both grain-free and whole-grain versions
Who should buy:
First-time natural food buyers or multi-pet households needing budget-friendly options.
5. Ziwi Peak (New Zealand) — Premium Air-Dried Superfood
Why it stands out:
- 96% meat, organs, and bone
- Air-dried technology preserves nutrients
- Extremely high digestibility
- Great for picky eaters
Who should buy:
Pet owners seeking the closest option to raw feeding but with convenience.
4. Five Expert Tips to Avoid Buying Fake or Low-Quality “Natural Food”
1. Read the First 5 Ingredients
If the top 5 items are not fresh meat, choose another brand.
2. Check Certifications
Look for:
- AAFCO life-stage claims
- USDA Organic
- Non-GMO certifications
- Free-range or wild-caught labels
3. Match Your Pet’s Health Needs
- Allergies → Duck, salmon, lamb
- Kidney issues → Low-phosphorus formulas
- Obesity → Low-fat, high-fiber formulas
- Small breeds → Small-kibble options
4. Check Recall History
Use FDA Pet Food Recall database.
Avoid brands with multiple recalls in the last 2–3 years.
5. Always Do a 7–10 Day Transition
Signs of a good match:
- firm stool
- shiny coat
- normal appetite
- no itching or vomiting
5. Where to Buy Natural Pet Food in the U.S. (2025)
Online (Best Prices + Most Convenient)
- Amazon (Subscribe & Save discounts)
- Chewy (30-day return, even if opened)
- Petco / PetSmart websites
Offline (Best for In-Person Consultation)
- Petco
- PetSmart
- Local boutique pet stores
- Veterinary clinics (for prescription diets)
Tip:
Summer shipping can affect freshness—choose insulated or fast delivery.
Conclusion: Natural Pet Food Is a Long-Term Investment in Health
Natural pet food is not a luxury—it’s a health investment that can:
- reduce allergiesReduces allergies
- improve digestion
- support immune systems
- extend your pet’s lifespan
In 2025, U.S. pet parents are more health-conscious than ever, and natural diets are becoming the new standard. By understanding labels, certification rules, and your pet’s unique needs, you can confidently choose the safest and most nutritious food for your furry family member.
This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
(Note: Prices and product availability are subject to change; please refer to Amazon for the latest updates.)
You May Also Like:
1.Best Cat Carriers 2025: Top Picks for Comfort, Safety & Everyday Travel
2.Best Smart Collars For Dogs 2025: Top Picks for Tech-Savvy Pet Parents
3.Indoor Cat Essentials Checklist 2025: Everything Your Feline Needs for a Happy Home
4.Best Dog Dental Chews 2025 for Bad Breath, Plaque, and Gum Health
5.Best Dog Food Small Breeds 2025: Top Picks for Healthy, Happy Little Dogs